Nurses are required to inform patients or their legal guardians regarding the risks and possible outcomes of certain medical treatments. This is called informed consent. When a nurse fails to obtain informed consent from the patient in their care, this can jeopardize their professional nursing license. The concept of securing informed consent from a patient may sound fairly straightforward, but the circumstances surrounding obtaining informed consent, as well as the patient's relationship with their family members and medical team, all come into play.
At the Lento Law Firm, we understand the challenges nurses face in obtaining informed consent. Our Professional License Defense Team is dedicated to protecting the rights of professional nurses who have been accused of failing to obtain informed consent from a patient. We work tirelessly on your behalf to ensure that your livelihood and your professional career are protected. Contact our team today and tell us about your case, or call us at 888-535-3686.
What Is Informed Consent?
Informed consent is one of the basic principles of the healthcare system in our country. Informed consent is designed to ensure that every patient is given the legal right to make their own personal decisions about their treatment. The concept of informed consent is based on a patient receiving all the relevant information regarding their medical care. Informed consent is a process, not just a piece of paper that a patient signs. And nurses play a vital role in that process.
In order to satisfy the legal standard of informed consent, a few different elements must be present:
- When a patient agrees to undergo a treatment or procedure, their consent to that treatment must be voluntary. This means that the patient must be able to make their decision without any pressure or influence from their medical team, family members, or others. Their decisions must be made freely based on their values and preferences, and nurses are responsible for ensuring that patients feel empowered to make their own decisions.
- Patients must have the mental capacity to provide informed consent, whereby the patient has the ability to fully understand the information provided and make an informed decision. There are a few factors that may affect a patient's capacity to consent, such as age, mental state, or cognitive impairments. In situations such as those, the patient's legal guardian or healthcare proxy may need to become involved in determining the patient's consent.
- Informed consent means, quite literally, being informed. In order to agree to treatment, the patient must be fully informed regarding the proposed treatment, including the goal of the treatment, its side effects, any potential risks of the treatment, benefits of the treatment, and any alternative options that are available. This information must be communicated to the patient in a manner that the patient can understand by using appropriate language that avoids complicated medical jargon. Nurses play a key role here, often helping to clarify medical explanations, answering a patient's questions, and making sure that the patient comprehends everything they are consenting to. By ensuring that patients fully understand their treatment options, nurses are helping to protect patients' rights while also safeguarding their own professional responsibilities.
The Role of State Nursing Boards
State nursing boards regulate the practice of nursing, ensuring that nurses meet established professional and legal standards. These boards are responsible for setting rules and guidelines, as well as investigating complaints, issuing disciplinary actions, and protecting the public from unsafe nursing practices.
Nursing boards across the United States treat informed consent as a critical component of nursing care. While each state nursing board establishes the guidelines for obtaining informed consent and penalties for failing to do so, most nursing boards prioritize the following when obtaining informed consent:
- Accountability for Communication: Most state nursing boards emphasize that nurses must effectively communicate with patients about their care. In cases where patients are confused or have questions, nurses are expected to either provide clarification or refer the patient to the appropriate healthcare provider for further explanation.
- Documentation: Nursing boards across the country stress the importance of documentation when obtaining informed consent. Nurses are often responsible for ensuring that consent forms are properly signed and recorded in the patient's medical records. Nurses are encouraged to include additional documents, such as notes about any discussions the nurse had with the patient regarding their treatment or care. Failure to properly document informed consent can lead to disciplinary action, as it is seen as a breach of professional duty.
- Protecting Patient Autonomy: Nurses are expected to respect patients' decisions regarding their care. This includes supporting patients who refuse treatment, even if the nurse personally believes the treatment is in the patient's best interests. State nursing boards view any attempt to coerce or pressure a patient into accepting treatment as a serious violation of patient rights.
- Special Circumstances: There are certain circumstances where informed consent becomes more complex, such as in the case of minors, patients with cognitive impairments, or emergency situations. Nursing boards expect nurses to be familiar with state laws and institutional policies regarding these special cases. For example, nurses need to know when they are required to obtain consent from a legal guardian or when consent can be waived in a life-threatening emergency.
- Ethical and Legal Implications: Failing to obtain proper informed consent can have both ethical and legal consequences. Nursing boards, working in conjunction with state laws, may investigate any reports of failure to obtain consent and take disciplinary action that can include suspension or revocation of a nurse's license.
- Education and Training: Nursing boards across the country recognize that ongoing education is crucial for maintaining informed consent standards. Many boards require nurses to complete continuing education courses on ethics and patient rights, including informed consent, as part of their licensure renewal process. These courses are designed to reinforce the importance of obtaining proper consent and staying current with any changes in state laws or healthcare regulations.
While nursing boards share a common goal of upholding patient safety, the specific rules and consequences related to informed consent can vary from state to state. Nurses need to familiarize themselves with the regulations in their state of practice to ensure compliance.
Understanding the Importance of Informed Consent
Informed consent is grounded in the belief that every patient has the legal right to make decisions regarding their medical treatment. For professional nurses entrusted with patient care, ensuring informed consent from a patient is not just about obtaining a signed legal document; obtaining informed consent is essential to maintaining professional integrity and providing patient-centered care.
Professional nurses are often the first medical professionals that patients see when they visit a doctor's office or hospital. Informed consent requires that nurses provide clear, open communication with patients to ensure that the patient or their legal guardian fully understands the medical treatments, surgeries, medications, and care that are being proposed. This includes informing the patient of any potential risks to the recommended course of treatment and other alternative therapies available. Doing so is designed to empower patients, to give them control over their own healthcare decisions, and to ensure that they are not subjected to unwanted treatments. Nurses must make a professional assessment as to whether the patient or legal guardian fully comprehends the situation before moving forward with any treatment.
Failure to Obtain Informed Consent: Impact on Patients
When informed consent is not obtained, patients can suffer significant medical and emotional consequences. Medically, they may be subjected to treatments, procedures, or interventions they didn't fully understand or agree to. When a patient is not fully informed regarding the medical care they are about to receive, it can lead to complications, unanticipated side effects, or, in some cases, permanent harm. For example, a patient who undergoes surgery without being informed of all the risks may face adverse outcomes that they were unprepared for, both physically and mentally.
Emotionally, the failure to obtain informed consent often results in a breach of trust between the patient and healthcare providers. Patients trust their medical team to be open, honest, and transparent in their communication with the patient. When a medical professional withholds critical information, this can erode the patient's confidence in the healthcare provider and the treatment they receive. In some cases, this lack of trust is even broader and extends to the entire healthcare system, which can cause the patient to refuse medical care all together.
In other cases, the lack of informed consent may cause the patient to feel powerless about their own care. This violation of trust and betrayal of the relationship between the medical provider and the patient can be particularly concerning for patients who are suffering from chronic or serious illnesses, where a lack of control over their future health is already profound.
Failure to Obtain Informed Consent: Impact on Nurses
All nurses and other healthcare providers have a professional responsibility to build and maintain patient trust through the practice of obtaining informed consent. When a nurse fails to obtain informed consent from a patient, the consequences can be severe.
A nurse's professional license may be in jeopardy, their reputation is on the line, and their present and future career opportunities can be negatively impacted. An accusation of failing to obtain informed consent should be taken very seriously; part of the responsibility of a nurse is to make sure that patients fully understand their medical treatments and agree to receiving that particular healthcare.
Professional Consequences of Failing to Obtain Informed Consent
When a nurse fails to obtain informed consent from a patient in their care, one of the most immediate impacts is the risk to the nurse's professional reputation and job security. If a patient claims that informed consent was not obtained, the nurse may be subject to internal investigations by their employer or a formal complaint with the state nursing board.
Nursing boards, hospitals, and medical facilities are required to thoroughly investigate any complaints related to informed consent. These investigations can involve lengthy legal processes, multiple hearings, and extensive documentation reviews. While a nurse is under investigation for failing to obtain informed consent from a patient, they may be placed on administrative leave, which can be detrimental to the future of their professional careers and have a negative impact on the nurse's financial situation.
Nursing board investigations can result in disciplinary actions against the nurse, ranging from a warning to a suspension or even a revocation of the nurse's professional license. Disciplinary actions taken by a state nursing board are often made public, which can damage the nurse's professional reputation as well as their future career prospects. Even if the nurse is cleared of any wrongdoing, the accusation and investigative process can leave a mark on the nurse's professional reputation.
Long-Term Career Impacts of Informed Consent Violations
When a nurse is charged with an informed consent violation, the long-term career consequences can be profound. A state nursing board disciplinary action or a patient lawsuit regarding an informed consent violation can follow a nurse throughout their career, limiting opportunities for advancement and new employment. Many healthcare facilities perform exhaustive background checks and closely review a nurse's professional work history before making hiring decisions, and a past issue regarding informed consent could be a red flag. Employers may be reluctant to hire a nurse with any past legal or disciplinary matters on their record, especially if the case involved patient harm or a serious breach of professional standards.
When a nurse has their professional nursing license revoked due to an informed consent violation, they may encounter additional challenges when they try to have their nursing license reinstated. While every state has its own criteria and processes for reinstating a nurse's professional license, license reinstatement typically requires evidence of corrective actions, such as additional training, and may also require further legal proceedings. For nurses who lose their professional licenses, the path to regaining employment can be difficult, requiring both time and financial resources.
Nurses Have Rights Regarding Their Professional Licenses
When a nurse is facing an allegation of failing to obtain informed consent from a patient, it is important that they understand their rights regarding their professional nursing licenses. While allegations of patient neglect can be stressful and career-threatening, nurses have several legal protections and avenues for defending their licenses and maintaining their livelihoods.
Nurses Have the Right to Due Process
One of the most important rights that professional nurses have is the right to due process. This ensures that, before any disciplinary action is taken against the nurse, the nurse is given the opportunity to present their side of the story. Individual state nursing boards are responsible for handling investigations regarding a nurse's failure to obtain informed consent, and these boards are required to provide a fair and unbiased hearing. Nurses have the right to receive clear notification from their state nursing board regarding the complaint or the charges brought against them, as well as the evidence being used to support the claim. Nurses have the right to respond to the charges brought against them, submit their own evidence, and to provide witnesses who will testify on their behalf.
Nurses Have the Right to Legal Representation
When a nurse is charged with failing to obtain consent, they have the right to legal representation throughout the state board of nursing's investigative process, which can be a complicated process. A skilled attorney will make sure that the nurse's rights are protected, build a strong defense, and negotiate settlements or alternative disciplinary measures, such as probation or additional professional training, rather than more severe penalties, such as suspension or revocation of the nurse's license.
Nurses Have the Right to Appeal their Decisions
If the state board of nursing issues a decision that negatively impacts the nurse's professional license, such as suspension or revocation, the nurse has the right to appeal the decision. Every state board of nursing has its own appeal process, but most processes allow nurses to request a review of the decision by a higher authority or court. Doing so ensures that nurses have an opportunity to contest the findings or the penalties imposed, particularly if the nurse believes the nursing board's decision was unfair or not supported by sufficient evidence.
Understanding these rights is essential for nurses to protect their careers when facing allegations related to informed consent. By knowing the proper steps to take, nurses can actively defend their licenses and continue practicing while maintaining their professional reputation.
Simple Steps Nurses Can Take to Protect Their Licenses
There are several steps that nurses can take to safeguard their professional licenses, particularly when it comes to an issue such as informed consent. Understanding and implementing these measures can reduce the risk of legal or disciplinary actions and help ensure compliance with the state's nursing regulations.
-
Maintain Clear Communication
The cornerstone of informed consent is clear communication. Nurses should always ensure that patients fully understand the nature of a procedure or treatment, including potential risks, benefits, and alternatives. This can be done by speaking in plain language, avoiding medical jargon, and spending time thoroughly answering the patient's questions, which can help prevent any misunderstandings. Documenting these conversations in the patient's chart is essential. Proper documentation not only protects the nurse but also serves as a record of the informed consent process in case any issues arise. -
Follow Facility Policies
Every healthcare facility has its own protocols and policies regarding informed consent, and nurses should familiarize themselves with these procedures. Taking steps to make sure all of the appropriate forms are completed and signed and following up with physicians or other medical team members when additional clarification is needed can help avoid errors. Nurses not only have the responsibility to obtain informed consent but must also ensure that there is no uncertainty regarding consent, as this can lead to serious consequences. -
Continue Professional Education
It is important for all nurses to continue professional education and to stay up to date on all legal and ethical guidelines surrounding informed consent. By enrolling in continuing education courses and participating in regular training that is focused on patient rights, legal responsibilities, and evolving healthcare regulations, nurses can stay informed. Many state nursing boards require ongoing education as part of a nurse's license renewal, and this provides an opportunity to gain the latest policy information regarding informed consent and patient communication.
By taking these steps, nurses can protect their nursing licenses and reduce their risk of facing legal challenges, allowing them to continue providing high quality patient care.
Skilled Legal Team Dedicated to Protecting the Rights and Licenses of Nurses Accused of Failing to Obtain Informed Consent
When a nurse faces an allegation of failing to obtain informed consent from a patient in their care, the emotional and professional toll can be significant. A nurse who fails to obtain informed consent for a surgical procedure may face a lawsuit or disciplinary action. Nurses enter the medical profession with a desire to help and care for others; when those same individuals are accused of violating a patient's rights and potentially putting that patient in harm's way, it can be personally devastating. Investigations by the state board of nursing, hearings, and the threat of losing their livelihood can be stressful and overwhelming. We understand.
The Lento Law Firm's experienced Professional License Defense Team works with medical professionals across the country whose professional licenses are in question. We know the challenges nurses face regarding obtaining informed consent from a patient in their care. And we are dedicated to protecting nurse's rights and their professional licenses to ensure that an allegation of failing to obtain informed consent from a patient does not jeopardize their current employment and future careers.
At the Lento Law Firm, our team works tirelessly on your behalf through every stage of the process, from the state nursing board investigation to the hearings, to interviewing witnesses and collecting evidence, to building the strongest case possible on your behalf. Contact our offices today and tell us about your case, or call us at 888-535-3686.
